FDA Advisory Panel Gives a "Thumbs Up" To Continue Using EPO for Cancer Patients

According to Johnson & Johnson, a panel of advisors for the Food and Drug Administration, in a surprise decision, supported keeping Epogen, Procrit and Aranesp from Amgen and Johnson & Johnson on the market for use in cancer patients who are anemic from chemotherapy.

The advisor panel voted 13-1 to keep Amgen's Aranesp and J&J's on the market for use with chemotherapy. The recommendation was very surprising because over the last year FDA has scrutinized the drugs because of safety concerns and recently added new warnings to the labels. Many analysts expected further recommendations for restrictions. Although the advisory panel vote is non-binding, FDA usually follows the advice of its panels when making regulatory decisions. However, it is important to note that FDA has not followed the advice of several advisory panels in the recent past.

The positive advisory panel vote is good news for J& J and Amgen because billions of dollars in revenue are at risk for the cancer indication.  I bet that J & J and Amgen executives breathed a collective sigh of relief after hearing the news!  Maybe that loud noise I heard earlier today was the popping of champagne corks at J & J corporate headquarters in New Brunswick, NJ.  

To quote Mark Twain: “The rumors of my death have been greatly exaggerated” is particularly apt for Amgen and J &J after today’s decision.

Until next time….

Good Luck and Good Job Hunting!!!!!!

FDA Adds Black Box Safety Warning to EPO Drugs

Amgen announced today that US regulators added black box warnings to its erythropoietin drugs, Epogen and Aranesp. Similar warnings were also added to Johnson and Johnson’s Procrit which is licensed from Amgen. For those of you who don’t know, getting a black box warning on a drug label is like getting the “kiss of death” from a marketing and sales perspective. It certainly will not help sales of these products!

The new warnings approved by the Food and Drug Administration warn that the company's drugs increased death and accelerated tumor growth in patients with several types of cancer, including breast and cervical. Prior labeling warned of similar risks in other types of cancers.

The actions taken by the agency were not unexpected but suffice it to say there are a lot of unhappy Amgen and Johnson & Johnson employees in a Thousand Oaks, CA and New Brunswick, NJ

Until next time….

Good Luck and Good Job Hunting!!!!!!!

Amgen Executives Must Stand Trial in Stock Manipulation Case

A federal judge ruled that Amgen Inc. must defend itself against charges that it misled investors about safety concerns with its flagship anemia drug, Aranesp.

A US district court judge dismissed charges against five of nine Amgen officers and directors but left plaintiffs 30 days to amend their complaint in order to include those defendants. The investors, led by Connecticut Retirement Plans and Trust Funds, assert that positive statements made by company officials regarding the safety of Amgen's two anemia drugs, Aranesp and Epogen, were knowingly at odds with clinical studies that had raised concerns.

The plaintiffs assert, according to court filings, that they unknowingly purchased artificially inflated shares, between April 2004 and May 2007. In one instance, during its fourth-quarter 2006 conference call, Amgen announced results of a clinical trial that tested Aranesp in 939 patients with anemia from cancer. The Food and Drug Administration, according to court filings, described the study as "demonstrat(ing) significantly shorter survival rate in cancer patients receiving (anemia drugs) as compared with those (sic) receiving transfusion support."

Describing the results of the study during the conference call, Roger Perlmutter, a defendant and executive vice president of research and development, said, "We did not see a statistically significant adverse affect of Aranesp on overall mortality in this patient population, and so we conclude that the risk/benefit ratio for Aranesp in these extremely ill patients with anemia secondary to malignancy is, at best, neutral and perhaps negative."

Sounds misleading to me! It is unfortunate that companies compromise their scientific integrity and corporate reputation simply to boost their stock price in the short term. I think companies are slowly learning that if they are dishonest or disingenuous with the American public that the public will soon lose confidence in them and their products. This, in turn, will lead to a decrease in sales and ironically a reduction in company stock price. As the old adage goes “Honesty is always the best policy!”

Until next time….

Good luck and Good Job Hunting!!!!!!!!!!!!

Amgen Takes Another Beating

Can anything else go wrong at Amgen? FDA regulators said on Thursday that they were reviewing the results from two recent studies that provided more evidence of serious risks for some cancer patients treated with anemia drugs, sold by Amgen Inc (Epogen & Aranesp) and Johnson & Johnson (Procrit). For those you who don’t know, J&J licensed Procrit from Amgen so there is really little difference between J&J’s Procrit and Amgen’s Epogen. Aranesp is a second generation, longer-acting version of Amgen’s Epogen.

In the studies, researchers used  Aranesp or Procrit to elevate a patient's level of hemoglobin to 12 grams per deciliter or higher, although many patients did not reach that level. Current warnings on the drugs say hemoglobin levels should not rise above 12 for patients with cancer. The FDA said the studies showed that patients with breast or advanced cervical cancer who were treated with the drugs died sooner, or had more rapid tumor growth, than similar patients who were not given the medications.

Based on these new data, it is almost certain that the agency will insist on label changes to include strong warnings regarding the use of EPO drugs to treat oncology patients. Maybe there is a black box warning in Amgen’s future?

Amgen's stock hit a new 52-week low on Thursday, dipping down to $45.25 and closing at $45.69. It has traded as high as $76.95 in the last year but has taken a beating with the decline of its anemia-drug franchise.

The similarities between Amgen and Pfizer are becoming more apparent each day. Both are largest companies in their respective sectors (biotech and pharma) and have relied almost exclusively on blockbuster franchises (and weak pipelines) to bolster their stock prices! As you may recall, both companies have laid off large numbers of employees over the past year to cut costs. Maybe bigger (biggest) is not always better?

Until next time….

Good Luck and Good Job Hunting!!!!

A Second Biosimilar Version of EPO Gets Approved in Europe

As the debate continues to rage in the US about how to regulate biogeneric drugs, the European Medicines Agency (EMEA) has given the go-ahead to Hospira and Stada to sell their copycat version of Johnson & Johnson's anemia drug Procrit.

The European Commission approved Retacrit (epoetin zeta), a biosimilar version of erythropoietin (EPO), to treat anemia associated with chronic renal failure and chemotherapy. EMEA regulators determined that the drug was comparable in efficacy and safety to Procrit.

The EPO market is a large one and more than 250,000 patients in Europe are estimated to be treated with epoetin alfa, which is marketed under various brand names, Procrit (JNJ; US), Eprex (JNJ; Europe) and Epogen (Amgen; US). Worldwide annual sales of EPO drugs are estimated at more than $7 billion, $600 million of which comes from Europe.

The approval for Retacrit comes some three months after Novartis’ generics unit Sandoz got the first go-ahead in Europe to develop its version of epoetin alfa. Sales of Retracrit will begin in Germany in early 2008.

When are American pharmaceutical and biotechnology executives going to wake up and realize that they will lose millions in revenue to biosimilar competition?  I think the old adage; “If you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em” is apt when talking about the biogenerics industry.

Until next time…

Good Luck and Good Job Hunting!!!!!!!!